Karuturi Challenges Ethiopia Decision to Cancel Farm Project

William Davison
January 11, 2016 —
Karuturi Global Ltd., one of the largest investors in Ethiopia’s farm industry, is challenging the termination of its project, claiming the government broke the terms of its agreement with the company.

The Agriculture Ministry’s cancellation last month of the company’s 2010 lease is invalid as it didn’t follow procedure, contravened an investment agreement between India and Ethiopia, and wrongly accused the company of inadequate progress, Managing Director Sai Ramakrishna Karuturi said in an interview Jan. 5 in the capital, Addis Ababa.

“I don’t recognize this cancellation,” he said. The termination amounts to expropriation, which the bilateral investment treaty says must be accompanied by market-value compensation, Karuturi said

The government made the “painful decision” to cancel the contract because of a lack of progress, said Ethiopian Communications Minister Getachew Reda.

“If you cancel a project, what’s the point of negotiating?” he said in Addis Ababa on Jan. 8. “If he thinks he has a legal option, let him try it, but the government has been giving Karuturi extensions for a long time.”

Insufficient Development

Karuturi, based in Bengaluru, India, was one of the first foreign investors to lease land in Ethiopia after the government offered incentives and identified 3.3 million hectares (8.2 million acres) as suitable for commercial farming. None of the farms have reported any success in exporting crops and advocacy groups including New York-based Human Rights Watch say the program impoverished residents by displacing them.

The Agriculture Ministry’s land investment agency notified Karuturi on Dec. 28 that the lease was canceled because “development” occurred on only 1,200 hectares. The rest will return to a “land bank” for investment, it said.

The agreement stipulated that all 100,000 hectares of the area allotted should have been developed within two years, according to a copy of the accord given to Bloomberg by Karuturi.
The government didn’t provide a final map of the concession, effectively blocked $180-million of financing by enacting a cereal-export ban, and prevented diesel from reaching the Gambella region near the border of war-torn South Sudan in 2014 on national security grounds, Karuturi’s Ethiopia unit said in a Jan. 1 letter in response to the cancellation that it sent to Prime Minister Hailemariam Desalegn.

International Arbitration

Hassad Food, a subsidiary of the Doha-based Qatar Investment Authority, rejected an offer to make an equity investment in the project in April 2013, two months after it had formally expressed interest, according to letters provided by Karuturi. No one answered the phone when Bloomberg made calls to a spokesman for Hassad Food and the investment authority seeking comment.

The clearing of 65,000 hectares and building of 100 kilometers (62 miles) of dykes to manage floodwaters constituted development, Karuturi said. An investment of $100 million is evidence of implementation efforts and annual floods and government action prevented further progress, he said.

The ministry officially warned Karuturi about insufficient progress in April 2012 and in June, according to the letter.

Karuturi, which says it’s one of the world’s biggest producers of cut roses, planned to grow and process crops including corn, sugar cane and palm oil on the plantation. The company was unable to do so partly because the Trade Ministry’s 2012 refusal to allow cereal exports precluded the company from earning the foreign currency needed to pay back the promised $180 million of loans from Indian banks, Karuturi said.

Karuturi has obtained a court order protecting the lease and is prepared to seek international arbitration on the matter, he said.

Share Button
Disclaimer: We are not responsible for any losses or damages that may have caused by using our services. EMF declines all responsibility for the contents of the materials stored by users. Each and every user is solely responsible for the posts.
Posted by on January 11, 2016. Filed under NEWS. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

One Response to Karuturi Challenges Ethiopia Decision to Cancel Farm Project

  1. Menilik Wonji Reply

    January 12, 2016 at 12:58 PM

    THE Supreme Court of India said Bill Gates To Face Trial In India: Millions Of Children Poisoned By Vaccine! , he will face the ramifications of poisoning millions of Indian children with vaccinesBill Gates and his eugenicist foundation’s crimes against humanity finally caught up with him? If the Supreme Court of India has anything to say about it, he will face the ramifications of poisoning millions of Indian children with vaccines.
    A recent report published by Health Impact News shows that a vaccine empire built on lies can only go on for so long. The reports states:
    “While fraud and corruption are revealed on almost a daily basis now in the vaccine industry, the U.S. mainstream media continues to largely ignore such stories. Outside the U.S., however, the vaccine empires are beginning to crumble, and English versions of the news in mainstream media outlets are available via the Internet.”
    “One such country is India, where the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and their vaccine empire are under fire, including a pending lawsuit currently being investigated by the India Supreme Court.”
    If you aren’t aware of the key players in the vaccine mayhem being driven into African countries, they are:
    1. The World Health Organization
    2. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation
    3. PATH (Program for Appropriate Technology in Health, funded by the Gates’ foundation), and
    4. GAVI (Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization, also funded by the Gates’ foundation)
    Microsoft founder Bill Gates recently said in a couple of years India will lead the way in digital financial inclusion. Speaking at a panel discussion on Transforming India through digital financial inclusion, Gates, in association with NASSCOM, said they were helping the government implement its projects in sector. “The results will be magical once critical mass is achieved.”
    Minister of State for Finance Jayant Sinha said the idea was to create a plug-and-play platform for the apps – essentially the direct benefits given to citizens. He said the Indian model is different from the acclaimed Kenya model as it .
    “We have made it channel neutral. Whenever the ultimate transactions happens is where the commission is paid out. And there is also the Right incentive for consumer choice,” the minister said. He said while 90 per cent of NREGA payments are already going through bank accounts, the government was now working on health insurance and crop insurance.
    TRAI chairman R S Sharma said it was wrong to assume that technology is the barrier for Indian consumers. “Cost is the real barrier. No one is going to pay Rs 20 cost for a Rs 100 transaction. The cost of transactions has to come down for micro transactions,” he said, adding that it has to become as easy as making a phone call.
    Gates said while everyone associates his foundation with work in the health sector, few knew that they have been working on financial inclusion for over eight years and started with work on micro finance. Advocating cashless transactions, he said: “When there is need for face-to-face transaction it means cost would be too large.”
    Sinha said the architecture was in place for India to become a cashless society, but people’s behaviour will take time to change. “The consumer will decide when that will happen.”
    ..Bill Gates To Face Trial In India: Millions Of Children Poisoned By Vaccine!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *